diff --git a/src/routes/_components/timeline/Timeline.html b/src/routes/_components/timeline/Timeline.html
index 7efd9cb9..c33a4ffa 100644
--- a/src/routes/_components/timeline/Timeline.html
+++ b/src/routes/_components/timeline/Timeline.html
@@ -59,22 +59,6 @@
   import { observe } from 'svelte-extras'
   import { createMakeProps } from '../../_actions/createMakeProps'
   import { showMoreAndScrollToTop } from '../../_actions/showMoreAndScrollToTop'
-  import { get } from '../../_utils/lodash-lite'
-  import {
-    HOME_REBLOGS,
-    HOME_REPLIES,
-    NOTIFICATION_REBLOGS,
-    NOTIFICATION_FOLLOWS,
-    NOTIFICATION_FAVORITES,
-    NOTIFICATION_POLLS,
-    NOTIFICATION_MENTIONS,
-    FILTER_FAVORITE,
-    FILTER_FOLLOW,
-    FILTER_MENTION,
-    FILTER_POLL,
-    FILTER_REBLOG,
-    FILTER_REPLY
-  } from '../../_static/instanceSettings'
 
   export default {
     oncreate () {
@@ -143,59 +127,10 @@
         timelineValue !== $firstTimelineItemId &&
         timelineValue
       ),
-      currentInstanceSettings: ({ $currentInstance, $instanceSettings }) => (
-        $instanceSettings[$currentInstance] || {}
-      ),
-      timelineFilters: ({ currentInstanceSettings, timeline }) => {
-        if (timeline === 'home') {
-          return {
-            [FILTER_REBLOG]: get(currentInstanceSettings, [HOME_REBLOGS], true),
-            [FILTER_REPLY]: get(currentInstanceSettings, [HOME_REPLIES], true)
-          }
-        } else if (timeline === 'notifications') {
-          return {
-            [FILTER_REBLOG]: get(currentInstanceSettings, [NOTIFICATION_REBLOGS], true),
-            [FILTER_FOLLOW]: get(currentInstanceSettings, [NOTIFICATION_FOLLOWS], true),
-            [FILTER_FAVORITE]: get(currentInstanceSettings, [NOTIFICATION_FAVORITES], true),
-            [FILTER_MENTION]: get(currentInstanceSettings, [NOTIFICATION_MENTIONS], true),
-            [FILTER_POLL]: get(currentInstanceSettings, [NOTIFICATION_POLLS], true)
-          }
-        }
-      },
-      showReblogs: ({ timelineFilters }) => get(timelineFilters, [FILTER_REBLOG], true),
-      showReplies: ({ timelineFilters }) => get(timelineFilters, [FILTER_REPLY], true),
-      showFollows: ({ timelineFilters }) => get(timelineFilters, [FILTER_FOLLOW], true),
-      showMentions: ({ timelineFilters }) => get(timelineFilters, [FILTER_MENTION], true),
-      showPolls: ({ timelineFilters }) => get(timelineFilters, [FILTER_POLL], true),
-      showFavs: ({ timelineFilters }) => get(timelineFilters, [FILTER_FAVORITE], true),
-      itemIds: ({
-        $timelineItemSummaries, showReblogs, showReplies, showFollows, showMentions,
-        showPolls, showFavs
-      }) => (
-        $timelineItemSummaries && $timelineItemSummaries.filter(item => {
-          switch (item.type) {
-            case 'poll':
-              return showPolls
-            case 'favourite':
-              return showFavs
-            case 'reblog':
-              return showReblogs
-            case 'mention':
-              return showMentions
-            case 'follow':
-              return showFollows
-          }
-          if (item.reblogId) {
-            return showReblogs
-          } else if (item.replyId) {
-            return showReplies
-          } else {
-            return true
-          }
-        }).map(_ => _.id)
+      itemIds: ({ $filteredTimelineItemSummaries }) => (
+        $filteredTimelineItemSummaries && $filteredTimelineItemSummaries.map(_ => _.id)
       ),
       itemIdsToAdd: ({ $timelineItemSummariesToAdd }) => (
-        // TODO: filter
         $timelineItemSummariesToAdd && $timelineItemSummariesToAdd.map(_ => _.id)
       ),
       headerProps: ({ itemIdsToAdd }) => {
diff --git a/src/routes/_static/instanceSettings.js b/src/routes/_static/instanceSettings.js
index db45398b..83787f8f 100644
--- a/src/routes/_static/instanceSettings.js
+++ b/src/routes/_static/instanceSettings.js
@@ -6,10 +6,3 @@ export const NOTIFICATION_FAVORITES = 'notificationFavs'
 export const NOTIFICATION_FOLLOWS = 'notificationFollows'
 export const NOTIFICATION_MENTIONS = 'notificationMentions'
 export const NOTIFICATION_POLLS = 'notificationPolls'
-
-export const FILTER_REBLOG = 'reblog'
-export const FILTER_REPLY = 'reply'
-export const FILTER_MENTION = 'mention'
-export const FILTER_FOLLOW = 'follow'
-export const FILTER_FAVORITE = 'fav'
-export const FILTER_POLL = 'poll'
diff --git a/src/routes/_store/computations/timelineComputations.js b/src/routes/_store/computations/timelineComputations.js
index 35afbe32..26785190 100644
--- a/src/routes/_store/computations/timelineComputations.js
+++ b/src/routes/_store/computations/timelineComputations.js
@@ -1,5 +1,14 @@
 import { get } from '../../_utils/lodash-lite'
 import { getFirstIdFromItemSummaries, getLastIdFromItemSummaries } from '../../_utils/getIdFromItemSummaries'
+import {
+  HOME_REBLOGS,
+  HOME_REPLIES,
+  NOTIFICATION_REBLOGS,
+  NOTIFICATION_FOLLOWS,
+  NOTIFICATION_FAVORITES,
+  NOTIFICATION_POLLS,
+  NOTIFICATION_MENTIONS
+} from '../../_static/instanceSettings'
 
 function computeForTimeline (store, key, defaultValue) {
   store.compute(key,
@@ -10,6 +19,31 @@ function computeForTimeline (store, key, defaultValue) {
   )
 }
 
+// Compute just the boolean, e.g. 'showPolls', so that we can use that boolean as
+// the input to the timelineFilterFunction computations. This should reduce the need to
+// re-compute the timelineFilterFunction over and over.
+function computeTimelineFilter (store, computationName, timelinesToSettingsKeys) {
+  store.compute(
+    computationName,
+    ['currentInstance', 'instanceSettings', 'currentTimeline'],
+    (currentInstance, instanceSettings, currentTimeline) => {
+      let settingsKey = timelinesToSettingsKeys[currentTimeline]
+      return settingsKey ? get(instanceSettings, [currentInstance, settingsKey], true) : true
+    }
+  )
+}
+
+// Ditto for notifications, which we always have to keep track of due to the notification count.
+function computeNotificationFilter (store, computationName, key) {
+  store.compute(
+    computationName,
+    ['currentInstance', 'instanceSettings'],
+    (currentInstance, instanceSettings) => {
+      return get(instanceSettings, [currentInstance, key], true)
+    }
+  )
+}
+
 export function timelineComputations (store) {
   computeForTimeline(store, 'timelineItemSummaries', null)
   computeForTimeline(store, 'timelineItemSummariesToAdd', null)
@@ -41,11 +75,93 @@ export function timelineComputations (store) {
     getLastIdFromItemSummaries(timelineItemSummaries)
   ))
 
+  computeTimelineFilter(store, 'timelineShowReblogs', { home: HOME_REBLOGS, notifications: NOTIFICATION_REBLOGS })
+  computeTimelineFilter(store, 'timelineShowReplies', { home: HOME_REPLIES })
+  computeTimelineFilter(store, 'timelineShowFollows', { notifications: NOTIFICATION_FOLLOWS })
+  computeTimelineFilter(store, 'timelineShowFavs', { notifications: NOTIFICATION_FAVORITES })
+  computeTimelineFilter(store, 'timelineShowMentions', { notifications: NOTIFICATION_MENTIONS })
+  computeTimelineFilter(store, 'timelineShowPolls', { notifications: NOTIFICATION_POLLS })
+
+  computeNotificationFilter(store, 'timelineNotificationShowReblogs', NOTIFICATION_REBLOGS)
+  computeNotificationFilter(store, 'timelineNotificationShowFollows', NOTIFICATION_FOLLOWS)
+  computeNotificationFilter(store, 'timelineNotificationShowFavs', NOTIFICATION_FAVORITES)
+  computeNotificationFilter(store, 'timelineNotificationShowMentions', NOTIFICATION_MENTIONS)
+  computeNotificationFilter(store, 'timelineNotificationShowPolls', NOTIFICATION_POLLS)
+
+  function createFilterFunction (showReblogs, showReplies, showFollows, showFavs, showMentions, showPolls) {
+    return item => {
+      switch (item.type) {
+        case 'poll':
+          return showPolls
+        case 'favourite':
+          return showFavs
+        case 'reblog':
+          return showReblogs
+        case 'mention':
+          return showMentions
+        case 'follow':
+          return showFollows
+      }
+      if (item.reblogId) {
+        return showReblogs
+      } else if (item.replyId) {
+        return showReplies
+      } else {
+        return true
+      }
+    }
+  }
+
+  store.compute(
+    'timelineFilterFunction',
+    [
+      'timelineShowReblogs', 'timelineShowReplies', 'timelineShowFollows',
+      'timelineShowFavs', 'timelineShowMentions', 'timelineShowPolls'
+    ],
+    (showReblogs, showReplies, showFollows, showFavs, showMentions, showPolls) => (
+      createFilterFunction(showReblogs, showReplies, showFollows, showFavs, showMentions, showPolls)
+    )
+  )
+
+  store.compute(
+    'timelineNotificationFilterFunction',
+    [
+      'timelineNotificationShowReblogs', 'timelineNotificationShowFollows',
+      'timelineNotificationShowFavs', 'timelineNotificationShowMentions',
+      'timelineNotificationShowPolls'
+    ],
+    (showReblogs, showFollows, showFavs, showMentions, showPolls) => (
+      createFilterFunction(showReblogs, true, showFollows, showFavs, showMentions, showPolls)
+    )
+  )
+
+  store.compute(
+    'filteredTimelineItemSummaries',
+    ['timelineItemSummaries', 'timelineFilterFunction'],
+    (timelineItemSummaries, timelineFilterFunction) => {
+      return timelineItemSummaries && timelineItemSummaries.filter(timelineFilterFunction)
+    }
+  )
+
+  store.compute('timelineNotificationItemSummaries',
+    [`timelineData_timelineItemSummariesToAdd`, 'timelineFilterFunction', 'currentInstance'],
+    (root, timelineFilterFunction, currentInstance) => (
+      get(root, [currentInstance, 'notifications'])
+    )
+  )
+
+  store.compute(
+    'filteredTimelineNotificationItemSummaries',
+    ['timelineNotificationItemSummaries', 'timelineNotificationFilterFunction'],
+    (timelineNotificationItemSummaries, timelineNotificationFilterFunction) => (
+      timelineNotificationItemSummaries && timelineNotificationItemSummaries.filter(timelineNotificationFilterFunction)
+    )
+  )
+
   store.compute('numberOfNotifications',
-    [`timelineData_timelineItemSummariesToAdd`, 'currentInstance'],
-    (root, currentInstance) => (
-      (root && root[currentInstance] && root[currentInstance].notifications &&
-        root[currentInstance].notifications.length) || 0
+    ['filteredTimelineNotificationItemSummaries'],
+    (filteredTimelineNotificationItemSummaries) => (
+      filteredTimelineNotificationItemSummaries ? filteredTimelineNotificationItemSummaries.length : 0
     )
   )
 
diff --git a/tests/spec/125-notification-timeline-filters.js b/tests/spec/125-notification-timeline-filters.js
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..a43e5027
--- /dev/null
+++ b/tests/spec/125-notification-timeline-filters.js
@@ -0,0 +1,93 @@
+import {
+  settingsNavButton,
+  getNthStatusContent,
+  instanceSettingNotificationReblogs,
+  notificationBadge,
+  instanceSettingNotificationFavs,
+  instanceSettingNotificationMentions, instanceSettingNotificationFollows
+} from '../utils'
+import { loginAsFoobar } from '../roles'
+import { Selector as $ } from 'testcafe'
+import { favoriteStatusAs, followAs, postAs, reblogStatusAs, unfollowAs } from '../serverActions'
+
+fixture`125-notification-timeline-filters.js`
+  .page`http://localhost:4002`
+
+test('Notification timeline filters correctly affect counts - boosts', async t => {
+  let timeout = 20000
+  let { id: statusId } = await postAs('foobar', 'I do not care if you boost this')
+  await loginAsFoobar(t)
+  await t
+    .expect(getNthStatusContent(1).innerText).contains('I do not care if you boost this')
+  await reblogStatusAs('admin', statusId)
+  await t
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+    .click(settingsNavButton)
+    .click($('a').withText('Instances'))
+    .click($('a').withText('localhost:3000'))
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationReblogs)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationReblogs.checked).notOk()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.exists).notOk({ timeout })
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationReblogs)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationReblogs.checked).ok()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+})
+
+test('Notification timeline filters correctly affect counts - favs', async t => {
+  let timeout = 20000
+  let { id: statusId } = await postAs('foobar', 'I do not care if you fav this')
+  await loginAsFoobar(t)
+  await t
+    .expect(getNthStatusContent(1).innerText).contains('I do not care if you fav this')
+  await favoriteStatusAs('admin', statusId)
+  await t
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+    .click(settingsNavButton)
+    .click($('a').withText('Instances'))
+    .click($('a').withText('localhost:3000'))
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationFavs)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationFavs.checked).notOk()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.exists).notOk({ timeout })
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationFavs)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationFavs.checked).ok()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+})
+
+test('Notification timeline filters correctly affect counts - favs', async t => {
+  let timeout = 20000
+  await loginAsFoobar(t)
+  await t
+    .expect(getNthStatusContent(1).exists).ok()
+  await postAs('admin', 'hey yo @foobar')
+  await t
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+    .click(settingsNavButton)
+    .click($('a').withText('Instances'))
+    .click($('a').withText('localhost:3000'))
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationMentions)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationMentions.checked).notOk()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.exists).notOk({ timeout })
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationMentions)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationMentions.checked).ok()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+})
+
+test('Notification timeline filters correctly affect counts - follows', async t => {
+  let timeout = 20000
+  await loginAsFoobar(t)
+  await t
+    .expect(getNthStatusContent(1).exists).ok()
+  await followAs('ExternalLinks', 'foobar')
+  await t
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+    .click(settingsNavButton)
+    .click($('a').withText('Instances'))
+    .click($('a').withText('localhost:3000'))
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationFollows)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationFollows.checked).notOk()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.exists).notOk({ timeout })
+    .click(instanceSettingNotificationFollows)
+    .expect(instanceSettingNotificationMentions.checked).ok()
+    .expect(notificationBadge.innerText).eql('1', { timeout })
+  await unfollowAs('ExternalLinks', 'foobar')
+})
diff --git a/tests/utils.js b/tests/utils.js
index 601c90e4..19f61542 100644
--- a/tests/utils.js
+++ b/tests/utils.js
@@ -73,6 +73,8 @@ export const instanceSettingNotificationFavs = $('#instance-option-notificationF
 export const instanceSettingNotificationReblogs = $('#instance-option-notificationReblogs')
 export const instanceSettingNotificationMentions = $('#instance-option-notificationMentions')
 
+export const notificationBadge = $('#main-nav li:nth-child(2) .nav-link-badge')
+
 export function getComposeModalNthMediaAltInput (n) {
   return $(`.modal-dialog .compose-media:nth-child(${n}) .compose-media-alt input`)
 }